Skip to main content

26/11 Trial, Media and Capital Punishment


The 26/11 trial is barely over. People are patient. But the media isn't.

The shrill voice of news readers wants punishment to be delivered in the manner of 24X7 reporting. While waiting for the judgment, hysteria is being orchestrated more or less demanding a time table to hang the only 26/11 terrorist captured alive.

At the final stage of the trial, while the arguments are being heard on the punishment for those found guilty, an unseemly ‘debate’ is being carried on almost non stop in some of the TV channels. This borders on baying for blood, almost equating justice to revenge.

Debate on death penalty is relevant. In a very large number of democracies it is not on the statues.

But, in the present debate anyone who takes a moral position against capital punishment is almost made to look unpatriotic.

The discussion is not about leniency to a particular criminal. It is not on showing mercy or a lesser punishment.

Debate is not whether this particular criminal deserves capital punishment. It is for the court to decide on the quantum of punishment. Surely, not on public demand! Not by SMS polls!

And, it is certainly not right for the media to attempt influencing the judiciary - directly or indirectly.

Discussion is about capital punishment itself, in absolute terms: whether it should be there in the statutes at all. It is not about patriotism.

It is commendable that India, without dithering, tried the terrorist under the normal judicial process and brought the trial to a successful conclusion, at great cost. In contrast, USA finds it difficult to adequately deal with the terrorists within its judicial system.

There is no justification to whip up emotions while the Honorable Court is about to pronounce the verdict.

It will be a grave mistake to incite the public into thinking that executions must be carried out in the shortest possible time and preferably, it would appear, within days after the trial court gives the verdict. This is not how a sound justice system is supposed to work.

Once we accepted that a normal trial will be conducted and the due process of law will be allowed to take its course, we must have the trust and patience to allow that to run its full course.

The media must stop baying for blood and get back to the task of reporting and informing, seriously. That is surely more challenging and useful than orchestrating calibrated melodrama in an emotional news room.

PS:

Perhaps, it makes sense to keep the young terrorist to be condemned for a life in prison. Capital punishment may turn out to be the spurious martyrdom that the terrorist longs for. A quick and violent death is the easy way out: to escape from facing the reality of misdeeds and its personal consequences.

Note

According to Amnesty International, more than two-thirds of the countries of the world have abolished the death penalty in law or in practice. While 58 countries retained the death penalty in 2009, most did not use it. [http://www.amnesty.org/en/death-penalty]

Many countries, such as Mexico, Canada and most European nations, will not allow extradition if there is likelihood of death penalty for the suspect… [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extradition]

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Feku the Fraudster on a Throne

Feku the fraudster sat on a throne Feku the fraudster pulled a fast one A masterstroke! A masterstroke! Feku the fraudster set everything afire Now, put out the fire, put out the fire Feku the fraudster laughed, yelled and cried A masterstroke! A masterstroke! Feku the fraudster laughed, yelled and cried All the fraudster’s cows and toadies Went around, in circles, in circles Couldn’t put out the engulfing fire Feku the fraudster’s tail was now afire And, all over a burning hell fire. [17-Nov-2016] The Political Economy of Demonetising High Value Notes -  Jayati Ghosh

Is there a Spartacus out there? Among the IPL gladiators?

The irony is that film stars 'own' the team – i.e., the players! Our sports icons are now like gladiators. May be, not so brave. In awe and with fluttering hearts they mix with the glamorous stars of the show business and real business. Occasionally they remember: Hey boy! This one really owns me, my God! What have I got into? The gladiator partying with his owner! They do it, not because they always like to party after a bad defeat, but so be it, it is part of the deal, you know.  It is the new Compulsive Relaxation Therapy, prescribed by the IPL. Partying in prescribed doses is a lot more than mere fun. Also, it is good to party if the defeat was, perhaps, well and truly expected. May be, even anticipated. You know why! No rewards for guessing! If still in doubt, ask your bookie. It just happens that the celebrations get a bit wilder when the results go against the odds! In this format of the game, both losers and winners can rejoice! It is a great game, come o...

Learned Chief Justice of India & Good Friday: Needs to be better informed and sensitive in a multicultural society

Thought of not commenting on the controversy about the Hon’ble Chief Justice of the Indian Supreme Court insisting on holding an important meeting of judges on Good Friday, which is a national holiday. However, I am quite disturbed by the insensitivity or lack of deep awareness on the part of the learned Chief Justice, even after the matter has been discussed with him. The significance of such days, observances associated with such occasions, the place they have in the life of people who believe are truly matters that ought to be properly understood by officials at all levels of judiciary in any multicultural nation and society. Those at the higher levels of judiciary must be better informed and even be enlightened, if you will. In the true spirit of Easter, I would take a charitable view and assume he is not sufficiently informed. He, perhaps, is a little stubborn too, as those in such positions tend to be when confronted with their own weaknesses. There is another reason why I wou...